Looking Back on the Wii U: Why It Still Will Be Remembered Fondly By This Gamer


The Wii U is on its death bed. One could argue it’s been this way for years, but the full reality of the end of this era has been upon us ever since the announcement of the Nintendo Switch and Nintendo hammering home that it is a home console first and foremost. Nintendo of Japan has now announced that the Wii U is going out of production “soon”, which is the first official signal that the Wii U era is coming to a close.

To me, that means now is the best time to look back on what the Wii U was, why it failed, and how I’ll be remembering this system. Now, in the past I’ve stated quite publicly that the Wii U stands among my favorite consoles. Instead of re-explaining that reasoning, here is a Boss Man episode I did for Zelda Informer on this very topic:

For those that don’t have the time to watch this, essentially I break down the library for the system and explain how much I absolutely adore the games (digital, virtual console, indie, and full retail releases) and how amazing I feel the GamePad was for my personal use case (while recognizing it is not a use case that applies to most gamers). I declare it is my favorite system of all time. While reflecting back on those thoughts it’s entirely possible I overstated that and still consider the SNES to be the cream of the crop, but it’s extremely close, and if nothing else the Wii U is certainly one of the most underappreciated systems to be released, right up there with the SEGA Dreamcast.

However, the failure of a system like the SEGA Dreamcast and the failure of the Wii U (ironically, two systems that had some sort of screen in the controller) are not actually as relatable as some folks think. The Dreamcast wasn’t selling poorly during it’s lifespan. Released in September 1999, it sold 9.13 million units at retail until it was discontinued on March 31st, 2001. That means it sold roughly 6 million units per year, having been on store shelves for 1.5 years. That is higher than any year the Wii U was on store shelves. Extrapolate that to a typicical 5 year life cycle, and you could have seen sales upwards of 30 million. That’s not all too terrible, especially compared to the Wii U which will be on store shelves for about 4.5 years, but only has sales just north of 13 million, or roughly 3 million units per year. This makes their failure stories very different.

SEGA Dreamcast was really a victim of past failures, rather than being ahead of its time.
SEGA Dreamcast was really a victim of past failures, rather than being ahead of its time.

For SEGA, the Dreamcast’s failure wasn’t actually the Dreamcast’s fault. In actuality, it took SEGA so many hardware interations released in rapid succession to finally find a successful platform in the Dreamcast that unless the system lit the world on fire the way PlayStation 4 or Wii did during their first couple of years on the market, it was already earmarked for an early death before it even released. SEGA was already heading in a direction of needed change and a lacked the financial stability to wait out that era.

Nintendo’s Wii U was in a different stratosphere. Nintendo was coming off their most successful generation of hardware ever in terms of sales and profits, and the company has managed money so well over the years that they have enough money in the bank to withstand many sales failures for decades before reaching the same financial struggle SEGA found themselves in during the Dreamcast era. The Wii U’s relative sales failure instead can be attributed entirely to bad decision making and marketing from Nintendo themselves.

While I loved the GamePad, reality is that Nintendo’s own internal developers could rarely find an intuitive use of the GamePad that showed how it is advancing gaming forward. It felt like an idea they brought forth that really had no feedback from the developers at the company – which ultimately may be why the hardware and software divisions now rest under the same building. To tear down those barriers for communication.

The GamePad, front and center in the marketing for Wii U, may have been the system's biggest misstep for a multitude of reasons.
The GamePad, front and center in the marketing for Wii U, may have been the system’s biggest misstep for a multitude of reasons.

It tried to advertise itself first as a console for “gamers”, while not offering the sort of beefy hardware those sort of gamers expected. They then quickly lost third party support before launch and tried hard to pivot their messaging back to the Wii’s blue ocean strategy, failing miserably to do so. The name itself was confusing, but even worse… all the advertising for the system hid the actual system, focusing instead on the GamePad which made people feel like it’s just an accessory to the Wii. It’s a reputation that still follows the system to this very day.

Due to the lack of third party support, the Wii U suffered some of the biggest game droughts in the history of Nintendo’s hardware, often going many months, sometimes half a year, between retail game releases. The Wii U failed in many ways to make itself appealing, with Nintendo’s current president openly admitting that he didn’t think the Wii U would be successful before it ever released.

All of this before touching on the complete fading off of the Wii brand Nintendo allowed to happen towards the end of the previous generation. Thus, for many of you it’s easy to remember the Wii U as a failure. A system with broken promises (No exclusive Zelda title, the end of game droughts, etc). Despite all of that negativity, I still see things in a completely different light.

Why the Wii U Will be Remembered Fondly by Me

At the end of the day, for all the faults the Wii U openly has (did we get into the online account mess yet? It just keeps getting worse), what matters most to me is content. To me, I’ll always remember the Wii U era for bringing Link into Mario Kart 8 (Animal Crossing too), the inventiveness of Splatoon, and the unique gameplay prospects of ZombiU and The Wonderful 101. I’ll remember the Wii U for having the best action game of this generation in Bayonetta 2 and possibly the best sidescrolling platformer in Tropical Freeze. I’ll remember all the amazing indie support and the various success stories associated, as Wii U owners flocked to the eShop craving new games to play.

For me, it's hard to deny the greatness of the Wii U's vast library of top tier games. (Image courtesy GoNintendo)
For me, it’s hard to deny the greatness of the Wii U’s vast library of top tier games. (Image courtesy GoNintendo)

It’s true that most if not all of the major games on Wii U will be ported and remastered on Nintendo Switch, likely becoming even better games for it, but I won’t forget where these games started. How Hyrule Warriors excited me in ways I didn’t think possible while Super Mario 3D World brought me and my girlfriend closer together, giving us a game we thoroughly enjoyed playing together until the very end.

I’ll always remember the many times I took the GamePad with me to the bathroom to continue gaming, or even the rare time while I took a bath (not a suggested way to use any electronic folks. Do as I say, not as I do!). Of course, that convenience ended once we moved out of the apartment and into a home last year. The complaints on communication distance became even clearer and more understanding. At the apartment I could still get a signal two floors down in the laundry room, but that was mostly attributed to really thin walls. At a proper house, you really couldn’t move outside of the room the system was in.

Still, I was able to game comfortably on my couch as my kids watched the latest Team Umizoomi or Spongebob. It’s a convenience I no longer need with a bigger home and multiple TVs, but one I will always appreciate for having at that given time (and it’s one, technically, the Nintendo Switch will still have).

While the only account system was far from perfect, I had a blast using Miiverse and conversing with fellow fans. I enjoyed the numerous talented individuals on display making the most of the limited artistic tools at their disposal. I loved that I never needed to pay to play online. It’s something I really never knew I wanted after getting use to just simply ponying up for Xbox Live. Yeah, PC gaming has always been free too to game online, but I just never viewed consoles in that light. Wii U made me appreciate that reality and hope for a better tomorrow.

Most importantly, the two primary controller methods just felt good. The GamePad was light enough to not cause fatigue and brilliantly designed for someone like me, who has rather big hands compared to my stature. The pro controller itself is arguably the best of the best. While it could have used analog triggers for greater accuracy and control, it’s hard to argue with a battery life that goes just over 80 hours on a single charge – literally no other wireless controller has ever given me that before. It’s also extremely comfortable and allowed me to have a seamless transition from GamePad to Pro Controller, and back again.

The Wii U isn’t perfect. Its flaws are perfectly stated by many in the industry and completely correct and agreeable. I can’t deny the system’s many pitfalls. But for me, for this singular gamer, it provided exactly what I wanted and needed for a short period of time in my life when I needed that little something different. I am firmly ready to make the “switch”, all puns intended. Still, I’ll always fondly look back on the era of the Wii U as one of my favorite in all of gaming, because it gave me lasting memories of pure joy I’ll never forget.

Nathanial Rumphol-Janc

A veteran in the video game media sphere, Nathanial co-founded Gamnesia, founded MetroidWiki.org, ran the news the segment on the Zelda Universe Podcast, found and ran Zelda Domain from 1998 to 2006, and built Zelda Informer as the Editor-in-Chief from 2008 to 2017. He now owns and operates Nintendo Prime. You can follow him on twitter @NateJanc, otherwise just stay tuned at Nintendo Prime for more of his work.

  • Wayne Robinson

    I don’t think the wii u was meant to be a big seller i mean Nintendo have not really advertised it, the 3ds was more of a concern but the Switch will be a different kettle of fish, but of course most will look at wii u as a failure, why compare with the Dreamcast? Sega was in big trouble in those days and nearly went under, Nintendo know what they are doing and there characters and games are loved and known by virtually everybody in the world and are not in any such trouble that Sega was in the days of the Dreamcast, BRING ON THE SWITCH!

    • Nintendo has already stated they thought the Wii U would be a 100 million unit seller. They definitely expected it to be a massive seller.

      The 3DS bounced back after not having any games and releasing at a price point that was too expensive for it’s given market.

  • Dampf

    For me, Wii U was a complete failure. No Metroid, no F-Zero, no exclusive Zelda, no real 3D Mario and no real Paper Mario (not saying Color Splash was bad) Not to mention the hardware and marketing sucked ass. Really the worst area in Nintendo history.
    I will keep mine though, I guess it will be worth good money in the future.

    • No “real paper Mario”.

      *looks around*

      Oh wait, color splash is one of the best paper mario’s in the entire series. I guess I must have dreamed that game and it doesn’t exist? Seems pretty “real” to me.

      • Dampf

        It get many things right, but you can’t deny that there are many flaws in the gameplay.

  • clinta

    I definitely agree with you that the Wii U is a great console. It’s sad that it didn’t do better sales wise. I’ve seen a lot of people complain about it. That’s true for a few owners of it, but a lot of people who don’t. Just like a lot of other Nintendo systems, it has a vast library with rich gameplay. Even games like Star Fox Zero had a new way of controlling aiming and flying. ZombiU was on of my favorite games even though apparently it didn’t score well in a lot of reviews. I don’t remember any times where I didn’t have something to play. I guess history will see it as a failure, but I don’t see it that way.

  • Sean Darko

    Without a doubt the Wii U was nintendo’s worst console with its misicule library, lack of support, and a half-assed online infastuctre.

  • Zachary Perea

    RANT: You all can keep going on about how the Wii U as a failure and all. And Nintendo is dying and going out of business. But remember, Nintendo Still has more net worth than PlayStation and Xbox. Now you could argue that Microsoft has more net worth but keep in mind most of that is off the back of Microsoft WINDOWS; not Xbox. And Nintendo has made most if not all of that on their video games alone. /rant over.

    Now that being said I feel the WII U was a great console. I mean who says you need an exclusive Zelda, Mario, ect game to be a good console? As for F-zero…well there hasn’t been a new one of those since the gamecube era, and it was trash. Also smash 4 was an amazing game with an amazing lineup. And it far outclassed Brawl.